Comments on My Makeup Reviews: Review: BeneFit Creaseless Cream Shadow/Liner - #1...

prettybeautiful: it's 2 coats on my skin. it's ver...

2008-07-16T15:47:00.000+08:00

prettybeautiful: it's 2 coats on my skin. it's very pigmented as it's a cream shadow.

Skinny Jeans looks awesome on your eye lid! is tha...

2008-07-16T14:53:00.000+08:00

Skinny Jeans looks awesome on your eye lid! is that just a single swap?

melanie,you are most welcome. but please bare in m...

2008-07-16T09:33:00.000+08:00

melanie,

you are most welcome. but please bare in mind that many people say that Erika F. and Skinny Jeans are totally different.

As I am light skinned Asian so my skin tone is a bit ashy and yellow so the two shadows show up on me roughly the same. But since you try to avoid green, then Skinny Jeans is definitely a right choice compared to Erika F. which is quite green.

Thanks for the comparison to Erika F! That was ext...

2008-07-16T07:53:00.000+08:00

Thanks for the comparison to Erika F! That was extremely helpful, as I have wanted Erika F for awhile. After looking at the swatches, I realize that it is too greenish for my taste and Skinny Jeans is really more along the lines of what I am looking for (and easier for me to find as well!)

Thank you!

Anonymous: thank you very much for the reply & com...

2008-07-15T16:57:00.000+08:00

Anonymous: thank you very much for the reply & compliments.

OK, I smelt, smelt and smelt both Shisedio HP and BeneFit Creaseless right up to my nose! Where is the smell? I couldn't smell a thing... I checked the ingredients agaian and there is no indication of any fragrance added. Could it be an old tester that you smelt? I honestly didn't smell a thing.

btw, I uploaded pictures of swatches on Erika F. and Skinny Jeans side by side. They really do look similar to me!

I give up... LOL

wow, great review! I went to check them out yester...

2008-07-15T13:15:00.000+08:00

wow, great review! I went to check them out yesterday (as hydropowders are my HG and you said you liked these even better). But too bad I had to smell it :( Is it just me or does it have a sent? But anyways, you did a really good job reviewing it. You're good at not being bias!

Haven't tried these yet but excited to now since y...

2008-07-15T01:33:00.000+08:00

Haven't tried these yet but excited to now since your review.
BTW, have you checked out the ones that are being discontinued on benefit's site? They are discounted!

heather: Thanks for reading my review. I'd suggest...

2008-07-13T07:25:00.000+08:00

heather: Thanks for reading my review. I'd suggest you trying out one shadow first instead of getting a bunch just in case it doesn't work for you. (TOUCH WOOD!) Good luck and please do let me know if how you like it when you try.

Great review! I've been wanting a good cream shado...

2008-07-12T21:32:00.000+08:00

Great review! I've been wanting a good cream shadow forever but have a problem with creasing because I have a hooded eye. I'm going to buy a few of these based on your experience.